I had never watched anyone die before. Probably as close as I had come to witnessing death was at the movies, which turns out to be as accurate as how the glitzy hamburger photos on a fast food menu resemble what actually comes in the box.
Mom was ready to depart. She was days away from turning 93 and her knees, hip, and neck gave her constant pain. She’d beaten cancer five months earlier but it was back with a vengeance, and she did not want to endure more treatments. She had a PET scan done for a new diagnosis and within a week of that commenced to fade quickly. We were still thinking she had a month or two left.
Home hospice care was called in on Tuesday for 8 hours a day. My sister called on Wednesday afternoon and said I needed to drive down Thursday. When I arrived in California Thursday evening, home care had already expanded to around-the-clock.
When I arrived, Mom gave me an angelic smile of recognition and beamed me her love, but she would only speak in a few scattered words. I knew she heard me but her responses were brief. Meanwhile, her prognosis had already shifted from months to days.
FACING IMMINENT DEATH
We all have our own ways of perceiving death. Over the years, mine has become romanticized, something Frank Capra could have cooked up. I like the idea of seeing spirits pop out of their physical bodies and float away to ecstasy. I have read a huge amount of near-death experience accounts, seen videos, and talked to people whose consciousness left their bodies. Those depictions tell of a blissful out-of-body freedom.
Although I was not thinking about it at the time, Mom’s death was a preview of my mortality. I was most intrigued about what she would experience—as if this would be her final act of guidance as a parent.
No matter how much I prepared for my mother’s end game, actually being there was profound. I did not feel that I had unfinished business with her, for we had talked during my previous visits and on the phone. Yet still I wished I had explained more to her what I knew about dying. She had not been that interested in woo-woo. She would listen politely, but didn’t share my passion for exploring cosmic mysteries. She wouldn’t ask probing questions and was skeptical of any of my sources.
Under those circumstances, I usually keep my opinions to myself. But when one of the caregivers said that Mom had told her that she was afraid to die, I wished we had talked more. She had never expressed any fears to me and maybe had not even realized them herself until she faced it.
WAITING AND WONDERING
Around noon Friday flowers arrived from a dear friend. I took them in to her following Dad. Mom smiled. I mentioned the name Jolene and she clearly knew who that was. I sat by her side and held her hand and within minutes she fell asleep again.
I contemplated to the beat of my mother’s pulse. Here she is experiencing the quintessential question of life: what happens next? In her final hours of living, here I was steeped in literature yet hungry for real-life experiences to validate my cherished woo-woo leanings.
All the stories from the literature about death flashed through my eyes. Would Mom stare off into space and break out into an ecstatic smile as she looked beyond us at something we could not see? Would she open her eyes and give us a message from dearly departed friends and relatives? When she was gasping her last breath, would we see a glow emanating from angels coming to whisk her spirit away?
On Saturday, the daytime caregiver opined that she thought Mom had hours left, not days. The pinkish glow of her face was disappearing. She wasn’t waking to greet us. Sometimes she would open her eyes but them close them as if not seeing anything. She seemed to have no emotional response to anything. My Dad and sister noticed that the varicose veins that had plagued her most of her life had disappeared as if Photoshopped out of her skin.
DYING IS NOT WITHOUT HUMOR
The caregivers, intimately familiar with the signs of impending death, prepared us for what was to come. Janelle (name changed) was very interested in making sure that we could witness Mom’s final breath. She had asked several times for reassurance that we wanted to be there—some clients don’t. We waited in great suspense for something dramatic to happen like floating on a river anticipating a huge waterfall ahead.
Around 2 on Saturday afternoon, Janelle announced with urgency that Mom’s lips were turning blue. Her breath was shallow and she seemed to be going. Mom had not been responsive to voice all day.
We gathered around her and offered our sweet good-byes. You could imagine a talking Norman Rockwell painting. We told her about relatives she would see again, beautiful gardens, an atmosphere of light, a space filled with love stronger than anything she had felt on earth. We also expressed gratitude for her role in our lives, for being a great wife and mom, and that we would miss her for now and would meet again.
Of course we each had our own spin on it. Much of my input had come from accounts of near-death experiences I read, heard, or saw. Upon reflection, I can almost hear her thinking, “My son the dreamer.”
It was not looking like Mom would suddenly open her eyes and announce, “I just saw Mom and Dad and heaven is everything you say it is!” She uttered no mysterious “Oh, wow, oh, wow, oh, wow” as Steve Jobs had said a few hours before he was pronounced dead.
We were all pumped up for the final exit, but I guess Mom wasn’t ready yet. With all of us gathered around, Dad noticed that she still had a strong pulse.
The story came to light of an aunt’s death. She had remained alive for days while my cousin held vigil. Finally a nurse took my cousin aside and suggested, “Your mom could be waiting for you to leave so she can be alone to die. Your presence may be keeping her alive. Go home.” When my cousin reached her home a half hour later, my aunt had died.
With that in mind we told Mom that we were leaving the room for awhile. If she wanted to leave the planet, she had our blessing.
WAITING FOR THE EXPRESS TO THE STARS
Mom stayed around although she didn’t open her eyes. She breathed through her open mouth even though she had oxygen. Several people came over to visit Mom. Conversations were one-way. One of the neighbors, a super compassionate doctor, reported that Mom was relaxed and not in pain. No need for meds even though the hospice had supplied them in case they were needed.
Waiting for someone to die is a most thought-filled experience. What do we do? Keep the mood somber? Sentimental? Clinical? Light? You can tell where I was: my fantasy was that someone like Robin Williams would stand at my bedside cracking jokes until I died laughing (even if my body couldn’t laugh anymore.)
I became aware that many of us don’t broach the subject ahead of time of what we want if we’re in a situation like Mom’s. Much is left to chance and spontaneity. Those being left behind have to make the decisions for the one leaving. We played some of Mom’s favorite classical music and took turns sitting at her side holding her hand, talking to her out loud, talking inwardly to her spirit, praying, waiting for something to happen.
We also learned that the cultural background of the caregivers played a role. The day person believed in opening the windows so the soul could escape. The night person believed in keeping windows closed to keep evil spirits out.
COSMIC MYSTERIES
We had dinner that evening while the night worker cared for Mom. Shortly after 7 she announced that the signs were present again: Mom was heading into the sunset.
I have never seen a birth and had never seen a death, but this, despite all that it meant to my physical existence and to our family, was exquisitely beautiful. We gathered around her. We said more good-byes and I love yous and pleasant journeys. The caregiver pointed out the signs of Mom’s last moments. I still hoped for a pink or golden glow to bathe the room, but the cosmic mysteries remained stubbornly mysterious.
Mom died quietly, a natural as opposed to supernatural death. It was like watching someone sleep. She just stopped breathing. She took her last breath at 8:11pm and at 8:12 it was over. Her new life had begun.
Mom had seen my first breath, and I had seen her last.
Joshua,
Your beautiful account brought tears to my eyes and a lump to my throat once again. I do very much appreciate your appreciation and understanding of the soul’s journey.
I often feel frustration over comments I hear from the loved ones of a departed soul. They wonder why God is so unfair. My heart hurts for them in their pain but I wish they could know what a great blessing it is to be free from the physical dimension. The memories of my NDE still cause me to long for the moment when it is my time to go. I don’t get to say that out loud very often because it upsets people but I feel you understand what I mean.
Your words, “Her new life had begun” are awesome. Thanks for sharing your beautiful thoughts.
I have never read anything so beautiful and peaceful. It certainly gives a very deep impressive and gives way to intense thought on the subject. I’m glad each of you were present at times for each other.
Thank you for sharing. What a beautiful family and such a bittersweet? special time. It brought to mind my own maternal grandmother who died of cancer some time ago. I had moved back to my hometown and began to help my mother with grandma’s caretaking. She really hated that (gma not mom). I would be there during the day and mom stayed at night. Mom had been trying to work out both for quite awhile before I got there, just too hard. I’m rambling but I guess the point is that I had some time with my grandmother that I hadn’t had in a very long time. I learned things that even her kids didn’t know and though she fussed at me fussing over her, I think she understood me when I said that I loved doing everything for her just as she had always done for everyone else and I asked her if she wouldn’t let me (mom and everyone). Show her how we learned and appreciated her. I too noticed changes as her time grew near though I wasn’t sure that’s what was happening at the time but the thought felt right. One of the things she let me do was to lotion her hands, arms, legs and feet. Her circulation was bad and she was always cold. Rubbing and massaging the lotion seemed to help and it was a great time for talking. One night I hesitated going home but mom insisted I go to my own family. I hadn’t been home long and she called asking me back, it had happened and my mom needed her daughter. By the time I got there others shortly followed. The first and most profound thing that made me happy when I went in for that last sit down was that she was warm. Although she had already passed I felt she could see and hear me and I told her how happy I was that she was warm and again how much she was loved and gave my final goodbye.
I read this in the parking garage of the hospital that my father was recovering from a stroke in. It was cold and snowing, the roads icy and I was not looking forward to the drive from downtown Spokane to my sisters in North Idaho. It was the day we got the good news and the not so good. So I think I planted myself there in the car to process before not just facing the road, but also the reality of his stroke, that patents are getting older, I still have little ones at home etc. To be honest, feeling a lot overwhelmed. I don’t know why, I guess to buy some time, I got my phone out and the first thing I saw was this. I cried and laughed Josh. It was sweet and beautiful, hopeful and comforting. I needed some cleansing tears for sure. It was the first time I had. Thank you. What a gift and blessing you, her dreamer son, are.
Hi Josh,
Thank you for the beautiful account of your mothers passing. I am so glad that you shared this intimate time with everyone. From the signs that the hospice caregivers look for when death is immanent, to the different cultural beliefs of each caregiver. It’s a passage that each one of us will eventually take to continue on our individual journeys. I loved your mom too and it seems that she passed into death with the same grace that she showed in her everyday life.
Your comment that she saw you take your first breath and you saw her take her last breath brought tears to my eyes. As it reflected your deep and perfect love of your dear mother.
Dearest Joshua…My condolences on your mother’s passing…
I too watched life leave my father’s physical body almost three years ago…although it was not a peaceful exit…After moments of watching him struggle to stay…I leaned over, kissed his forehead and told him it was ok to go…within minutes he took his last breath…he was only 66. I will always be thankful to my brother for opening up the lines of communication between us before the doctors came in to intubate him…he asked Dad if he had any regrets..to which he replied, “No, I got to travel the world, raised 2 beautiful children…just please take care of eachother and your mother” Does our spirit continue on…the answer is yes…As we were gathering up his flowers, cards, etc…my 1 year old niece waved at something only she could see down the hallway…saying bye, bye, poppa…
In our talk before dad was coma induced..I had told him that I didn’t have a whole lot of memories with him… (as he was a long-haul truck driver and gone months at a time to support us) and was sorry we didn’t spend as much time together as we should have…both of us just to busy
The day of his passing he gave me 2 gifts…. One day had been a very difficult day..a crappy nurse..who kept turning his oxygen down and trying to bring him out of the coma too quickly…so i decided to go for a walk to release some anger…as I passed the gift shop i went in and a little box that looked like a stone with an eagle feather on it caught my eye…for some reason it reminded me of Dad and I thought to myself I must stop back and get it. I had totally forgotten about it and upon exiting the elevator to go home after his death…a voice booming in my head stopped me in the hallway and said…”Go get the box” Driving home the voice said…”take the box out of the bag” and right away I clutched it to me and it soothed my aching heart. The 2nd gift was the gift of my life and spirit back for in his passing it made me realize how short our time can be on this physical plane and I now try to live evry moment to the fullest.
He also stops by to visit every now and again in spirit…the first shortly after his passing…I was sitting at my desk when all the critters gathered around me…more like mauled and I’m telling them to go leave me alone…when My Lace girl wrapped her paws around my neck and pulled my head to her chest and would not let go…I began to sob uncontrollably and then I realized it was dad’s arms around me..I could even smell that scent that is unique to each of us…
Wow….Josh…for some reason I checked your Facebook today and saw this. I’m so sorry about your loss, but at the same time, your piece about the experience touched me deeply. I think you were blessed to be able to be there when she passed.
Hi Joshua,
I’ve reposted the first part of Death at Home at My Embellished Life. It’s been tweeted, updated on Facebook and posted to LinkedIn. I hope you attract many more readers to your blog. And, if you send anyone over to mine, please ask folks to Google + your post (or any other that they like). This will help us all increase our readerships. Warm regards, d
http://donnabarker.blogspot.com/2012/03/death-at-home.html
Ready this post after finding on The Embellished Life blog. It inspired me to write an essay about my mother that I’d been thinking about doing for months. Beautiful story, and thanks for the inspiration.
Beautiful Josh, a perfect tribute to your Mom’s passing and the joy and the mystery that awaits all of us as we breath for the last time.
Much love,
Shekinah